They also pleaded not guilty to possessing the Class B drug amphetamine.
Shepherd was not Eli's natural father but had moved in with Cox in the month of his birth.
But, this specific date gets super awkward, super fast.
After the man gushes about how he wants the whole package (the kids, the house, etc.), the woman reads on her dating app that he had written "never getting married" on his profile.
She also told officers that Shepherd - who called himself 'Pickle' - was performing adult CPR on him.